An Even Playing Field?

This weekend sees the return of the Edinburgh Mela.  For those who don’t know, Edinburgh Mela is a festival of world music, dance, fashion, food and fun, embracing the city’s diverse communities and cultures.  The idea is that by providing the population with music, dance and other arts from around the world, the festival can help in “promoting understanding between people and advancing the cause of community coherence.”  Not only that, but you can enjoy some of the best food around.

Like most people in Edinburgh, I’m looking forward to the Mela’s return.  The trouble is, there’s a problem with how they are treating Leith Links, which has acted as host since 2010.  You would think that as part of advancing community coherence, the Mela would make sure they take care of the location where they pitch their tents and stalls.  After all, the Links are the principal open space within Leith, totalling 18.5 hectares and contain children’s play areas, football pitches, an enclosed lawn bowls bowling green and a cricket pitch.  Most of these are in the Links’ western section, while the eastern one is used for general use.  Leith Athletic, a community football club, is one of the groups that makes use of the Links’ pitches.  They have teams competing in the East of Scotland senior league plus youth teams from the under 6’s up to the under 21’s.  They’ve also recently launched a girls’ team and are trying to find enough particpants to form Under 9 and 11 teams.

Sadly, though, the club has postponed games and training as the areas they use on a weekly basis are now fenced off in preparation for the Mela.  To make matters worse, there are now tyre tracks all the way to the main marquee, which is pitched right in the middle of the soccer 7s pitch.  These are pitches that Leith Athletic volunteers taking care of, including making sure the grass is cut to a suitable length and painting the lines.  When you combine the recent rainfall and the Mela’s footfall – somewhere in the region of 27,000 people – that means this pitch will probably be unplayable for the next few months.  Another area of the Links, where the club have their main pitch, is currently covered in tyre marks despite claims that organisers would ensure boards were placed on the grass to allow vehicles to drive materials onto the Links.  This clearly has not happened, as you can see in these photographs.  In fairness though, the Mela are not the only culprits when it comes to taking care of the Links, the circus and the shows also cause damage when they visit.


According to the Mela’s webiste, they are taking steps to manage the event in a more sustainable way and reducing its environmental impacts.  That all sounds well and good but they don’t seem to care about the impacts, environmentally or otherwise, their actions are having on other members of the community, with whom they share the site.  If the Mela is about the community growing closer together than a good place to start is with mutual respect and consideration.  Sadly, that seems lacking in this case.

Leith Athletic accept that they do not have sole use of the Links as it is a park for all the community.  However, they do expect people to treat the area with respect, leaving it in the same condition they found it to ensure it’s in a fit state for others that use it.  From what I have learnt this afternoon, the Mela and Edinburgh Council do not share these beliefs.  Now, the community club are faced with repairing the damaged areas and finding funds to pay for this cost.  Perhaps Steve Cardownie, deputy leader of City of Edinburgh Council and Chair of the Mela’s Board of Directors, could help by spending some time helping to make the area good again.  Maybe the Mela will even undertake the repairs themselves.  Of course, if they had used boards to protect the Links or sited the festival on the park’s eastern area, they wouldn’t have to.



I did contact the Mela to see if they had any comment.  So far they have not responded to my phone message or the tweet I sent to their official account.

Since publishing this post, their Twitter account has contacted me twice.  The first time was to ask where the complaints are so they can respond to them, the second time to say they will “have a full response tomorrow. Please note the Mela have paid a bond to the council to cover any damage.”  That’s good to know but they could have avoided losing that bond and damaging the Links by using boards to protect the grass, as they were supposed to do.

About LothiansKen

I'm a middle classed kiddie, but I know where I stand.
This entry was posted in General Posts. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to An Even Playing Field?

  1. The Mela is based out of Leith, run from and as part of the community. Good relationships with that community, and the preservation of Leith Links, are as important to us as everyone else in the area: after significant feedback from the community we’ve taken extensive steps this year to ensure any impact on the environment is minimised: it’s something that’s of paramount importance to us, and we care very deeply about our long-term impact on the area and community. We’ve been in constant contact with the Parks Department, and as Ken noted in his blog, we both pay rent for use of the space and have paid a significant bond to the council against ground damage and repairs. We have, as promised, placed trackway down at entrance and exit points to protect the most vulnerable parts of the site. We’ve never made a statement claiming that we were going to lay trackway down over the whole site, and we’ve never been asked to.

    What we’ve been unable to legislate for is the weather. Almost every outdoor event in the country has been affected by the unprecedented amount of rainfall this year: following 24 hours of rain on Monday, and yesterday’s torrential downpour, the grass on Leith Links has been left extremely boggy and more prone to wear than we could have anticipated. We’ve been regularly halting production around the Mela site to preserve the space as much as possible: we temporarily ceased all movement of vehicles on the site yesterday following the huge amounts of rain, to allow the site some time to recover.

    We’ve particularly taken extensive steps this year to ensure that the two main marked football pitch areas are left untouched. Our director has been spending his days on the site personally ensuring that vehicles do not drive over the main football pitch areas: we’ve erected fencing around them and have been making sure that all drivers and staff coming to the site understand the boundaries. The small 7-a-side pitch marked where we’re erecting our World Dance Feste tent was not marked as a football pitch when we submitted our plans (which were created through extensive consultation with Leith Links Community Council) to Edinburgh City Council in May. The pictures above, taken from the Facebook page, are also misleading; whether or not Leith Athletic is one of the many local organisations, including the Mela, who make use of the specific area in their pictures, that particular space is not marked out, nor formally reserved, as a football pitch. We did approach Leith Athletic early in the year, intending to suggest that their youth groups might like to participate in the Mela and to look at ways of co-operating; our overtures were rejected and no discussion occurred.

    Ultimately, Leith Links is a shared public park space, and we’re a publicly-funded organisation, using a section of that space to try and bring the local community together. We believe that the benefits the Mela brings to Leith are significant; we’ve taken equally significant steps to minimise the damage this year. That there will be some damage to the ground is inevitable with any event of this size, especially after the rainfall this year, but we’re trying our best – in very difficult weather conditions – to keep it to a minimum, and our bond is there to cover any costs incurred in repairs.

  2. LothiansKen says:

    Leith Athletic have now have now also issued a statement regarding the current state of the Links. You can read it on their site ->

  3. Ann says:

    It’s a pity one of the walkway’s was removed before the porta loos were taken away, the lorry sent to pick them up got stuck in the mud and had to wait quite a while before being helped out. Pity about the mess that was left at the end of the mela but at least the seagulls had a good feed as did a few of the local dogs, here’s hoping they don’t get sick eating the muck that was left. Pity the mela didn’t insure that the water buts were emptied, stall holders were seen taking the pipes from the buts and emptying the water onto the grass. Whilst the Mela is an enjoyable festival it needs to be moved to a more appropriate site.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s